Why insurance matters for charities

This charity insurance guide explains how charities can get the right cover, manage costs, and avoid common pitfalls. Having the right insurance is essential for any charity that owns or occupies property, runs services, or works with staff, volunteers, and the public.

Many charities pay more than they need to, or discover too late that their cover doesn’t match their real risks. Getting the “best” insurance deal isn’t just about finding the cheapest premium – it’s about making sure your charity is properly protected, understands its responsibilities, and avoids gaps that could expose trustees to financial and legal risk.

Understanding your insurance cover

Understanding what your insurance actually covers is the first step in making sure your charity is properly protected. Many charities assume they are insured for “everything”, but policies often contain gaps, exclusions, or limits that only become obvious when something goes wrong. This section explains the key questions to ask so you can be confident your cover reflects your real activities and risks.

What questions should charities ask about their insurance?

Before renewing or taking out a policy, charities should take time to review their cover and ask some fundamental questions.

Is everything we do actually covered?

Check that all of your activities are included, for example:

  • Services delivered on your premises
  • Events and outreach work
  • Activities involving volunteers
  • Equipment or items taken offsite

Many policies only cover what is explicitly declared, so new or unusual activities may not be included by default.

What exclusions and excesses apply?

Every policy contains exclusions (what is not covered) and excesses (what you must pay towards a claim). Ask:

  • Which sections of the policy have the highest excess?
  • Are there any major exclusions that could affect your core work?

Understanding these details helps avoid unpleasant surprises during a claim.

Are we missing any important types of cover?

Depending on your activities, you may need more than just basic property and public liability insurance. Common gaps include:

Not all charities need all of these, but many assume they are covered when they are not.

Do we understand the claims process?

Trustees and managers should know:

  • How to report a claim
  • What evidence is required
  • What responsibilities the charity has during a claim

Poor claims handling can delay payments or even invalidate cover.

How does our policy compare with others?

Even if you’re happy with your current insurer, it’s useful to know:

  • Whether the price is competitive
  • Whether the scope of cover matches what similar charities have

This doesn’t always mean switching, but it does strengthen your position.

Managing costs and avoiding common mistakes

Managing insurance isn’t just about reducing premiums — it’s about avoiding decisions that increase risk. To hear practical tips on keeping costs manageable while making sure your charity is properly protected, listen to our podcast episode Getting the best deal from your insurer, where EPF’s CEO Antonia Swinson and Jade Winter from Norris & Fisher explain what trustees should review, common pitfalls to avoid, and how to get better value from your policy.

How can charities keep insurance costs manageable?

Insurance premiums have risen significantly in recent years, particularly for property and liability cover. While costs may be unavoidable, there are practical ways to stay in control.

Review your policy regularly

Make sure your policy reflects:

  • Your current activities
  • Changes to your building or assets
  • New staff, volunteers, or services

Out-of-date information can lead to underinsurance or paying for cover you no longer need.

Shop around – but don’t underinsure

Comparing quotes can save money, but cheaper isn’t always better. Inadequate cover can cost far more in the long run than a slightly higher premium.

Look for discounts and risk management schemes

Some insurers offer reduced premiums if your charity:

Check broker and admin fees

Ask what fees are being charged and what services they cover. These can vary significantly between providers.

Make sure your cover limits are realistic

For example:

  • Do you really need £10 million public liability?
  • Is your equipment insured for replacement value, not original cost?

Too much cover wastes money; too little creates serious risk.

Avoid misrepresentation

Failing to disclose relevant information (even unintentionally) can invalidate a policy. This can also create personal liability issues for trustees.

What are the most common insurance mistakes charities make?

Some problems appear again and again across the sector.

Missing essential cover

Charities often overlook:

These risks may feel abstract until something goes wrong. Overlooking cyber insurance is a common mistake. To strengthen your organisation’s digital security and reduce risk, read our Top 10 Cyber Security Tips for Small Charities.

Focusing only on price

Low premiums can hide:

  • Narrow cover
  • High excesses
  • Significant exclusions

Value and suitability matter more than headline cost.

Not reviewing insurance after changes

New buildings, new services, or new ways of working (such as hybrid or digital delivery) should always trigger a policy review.

Underinsuring buildings and assets

Underinsurance is a growing problem, especially with rising construction costs. If a building is insured for too little, insurers may apply an “average clause,” meaning claims are only partially paid. For practical guidance on spotting underinsurance and ensuring your charity has the right level of cover, listen to our podcast episode Charity insurance underinsurance: Is your charity trying to save money?

Getting the right support and next steps

Insurance can be complex, and getting it right often requires more than simply reviewing your policy. Here we cover the benefits of expert guidance, the pitfalls to avoid when going direct, and the actions your charity should take next to stay protected.

Even with this guide, trustees may have questions about their buildings, assets, or property-related risks. You can use our Ask a Property Expert service for free, independent guidance on property matters, including how changes to your premises could affect your insurance and risk exposure.

Should charities go direct to insurers?

Buying insurance directly can sometimes appear cheaper, but it carries risks.

What are the downsides of going direct?

Direct policies may:

  • Lack tailored cover for charities
  • Exclude activities that a specialist would flag
  • Provide limited support during claims

Without expert advice, it’s easy to misunderstand what is and isn’t included.

What is the value of using expert advice?

Even charities that manage insurance internally can benefit from professional input.

Expert support can help with:

  • Identifying gaps in cover
  • Interpreting exclusions and policy wording
  • Getting fair treatment during claims
  • Improving risk management to reduce future premiums
  • Setting appropriate cover limits

For complex property portfolios or unusual activities, specialist advice is often crucial.

What should charities do next?

Charities should treat insurance as part of good governance, not just an annual admin task.

Practical next steps include:

  • Reviewing current policies in detail
  • Asking the key questions outlined above
  • Seeking independent or specialist advice where needed

Insurance is one of the main safeguards protecting a charity’s assets, people, and reputation. Taking time to get it right can prevent serious financial and legal problems in the future – and may also lead to better value for money.

With thanks to our contributors

We gratefully acknowledge Norris & Fisher (Insurance Brokers) Ltd, our corporate partner based in Southampton, for their expertise and practical input in shaping this article. Their experience supporting charities and community organisations, particularly village halls, has helped ensure this guidance reflects real-world risks and best practice in charity insurance.

Norris & Fisher logo – specialist insurance brokers for charities and non-profit organisations.

Scroll to Top